A child chews a painted block. Nothing visible happens, yet chemistry has started: saliva and stomach acid begin to strip traces of whatever sits in the paint film. EN 71-3, the European toy safety standard for element migration, is built around that exact scenario. It does not ask how much lead or barium a colorant contains. It asks how much can escape the material and survive a trip through a child’s stomach.
How EN 71-3 migration testing works
The method is deliberately rough because digestion is rough. A toy component is assigned to a material category, comminuted, and extracted for one hour at 37 °C in hydrochloric acid of about 0.07 mol/L, then left to stand for another hour. The liquor mimics gastric acid. Whatever dissolves into it is quantified, usually by ICP spectroscopy, and set against migration limits for 19 elements, with chromium split into trivalent and hexavalent species and tin split into inorganic and organotin forms. The 2024 amendment (A2) tightened the chromium VI limits, a reminder that this standard moves and old reports age.
Three categories decide the limit
Limits track how much material a child can realistically ingest. Category I covers dry, brittle, powder-like, or pliable materials; a wax crayon flake lands here. Category II covers liquids and sticky coatings, finger paints and transferable inks, and carries the lowest limits because swallowing is easiest. Category III covers material scraped off a surface with a blade. Lead shows the spread under the current edition: 2.0 mg/kg in category I, 0.5 mg/kg in category II, 23.4 mg/kg in category III. One pigment can pass in one part of a toy and fail in another.
Pigment chemistry that survives stomach acid
Migration is a solubility problem, and the pigment-dye divide explains most of it. Insoluble particles locked in a polymer matrix shed almost nothing. Soluble molecules keep diffusing through the plastic into sweat, saliva, and the acid extract. That is the core difference between pigments and dyes, and the main reason solvent dyes rarely appear in toy specifications.
Within organic pigments, the metal in the salt form decides the paperwork. The classic BONA reds make the point: the organic pigment table lists Pigment Red 48:1 as the barium salt, 48:2 as the calcium salt, and 48:3 as the strontium salt. Barium and strontium are both EN 71-3 elements. Calcium is not on the list at all. Same chromophore, same tinting strength, different compliance file.
| Colorant (C.I.) | Metal in the molecule | Site-listed heat stability | Consequence under EN 71-3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pigment Red 48:1 | Barium (BONA salt) | 240 °C | Regulated element; every extraction carries Ba |
| Pigment Red 48:2 | Calcium (BONA salt) | 240 °C | Calcium absent from the 19-element list |
| Pigment Red 48:3 | Strontium (BONA salt) | 250 °C | Regulated element; Sr migration capped |
| Pigment Red 57:1 | Calcium (BONA salt) | 230 °C | Calcium absent from the list |
| Pigment Blue 15:1 | Copper (chelated) | 300 °C | Capped element, but chelation keeps migration near zero |
| Pigment Red 254 | None (DPP) | 300 °C | No metal available to migrate |
Blue adds a subtlety. Copper phthalocyanine carries a capped metal, but the copper sits inside a chelate ring so stable that the acid barely touches it, and phthalocyanine blues pass migration testing routinely. Iron oxides behave the same way, which is one reason oxide reds and yellows are common in outdoor toy coatings.
Choosing toy-safe colors
Selection reduces to three questions. Which metal sits in the pigment, if any? Prefer calcium salts, sodium salts, and metal-free chemistries such as quinacridone and DPP; treat barium and strontium grades as a documentation burden rather than an automatic fail. How soluble is the colorant? A spirit-soluble dye that stains fingers in use will also bleed into the acid extract, so keep solvent dyes away from mouth-contact parts and screen metal-complex dye grades for chromium, nickel, and copper. And what does the paper trail say? A declaration must carry the batch number, the method, and the lab name; the bare word “compliant” proves nothing, the same discipline the REACH SVHC colorants checklist demands on the candidate-list side.
Ningbo Ultra Color keeps toy-grade colorant selection on a documented footing. The test program described on its about page covers EN 71-3 alongside updated REACH SVHC screens and the six RoHS substances. Every batch of raw material passes laboratory checks, and retained samples are kept for five years, so any lot can be re-examined on request.
What should buyers ask about EN 71-3 and colorants?
Does EN 71-3 certify the pigment itself?
No. The standard tests finished toy materials, not colorants in isolation. A pigment earns its toy record only inside a specific compound or paint film at a specific loading. Ask the supplier for colorant-level element data and any migration history in comparable matrices, then confirm on the molded part.
Why would a barium pigment fail where the calcium grade passes?
Because the element list names barium and omits calcium. Pigment Red 48:1 and Pigment Red 48:2 share one chromophore. The barium salt feeds a capped metal into every acid extraction; the calcium salt feeds none.
How often do the limits change?
Slowly, then abruptly. The 2024 amendment recast the chromium VI limits after years of stability. Reports older than the current edition deserve a re-read before they back a new submission.


